Compartment syndrome after fracture or surgery: which expert?
An orthopaedic surgeon and a nursing expert for breach. An orthopaedic surgeon on what earlier fasciotomy would have saved.
Breach of duty
- Consultant orthopaedic surgeon
- Nursing expert (neurovascular observations)
Causation
- Consultant orthopaedic surgeon
- Plastic surgeon (for tissue loss and reconstruction)
Breach. Compartment syndrome is a surgical emergency, and claims usually concern delay in recognising it. The nursing expert considers whether neurovascular observations were done as often as required, whether pain out of proportion to the injury was noticed, and whether concerns were escalated. A consultant orthopaedic surgeon, or a surgeon in the specialty that operated, considers whether the medical team responded promptly and whether fasciotomy should have been done earlier. The standard is the guidance in force at the time, including the British Orthopaedic Association's standard on compartment syndrome.
Causation. Muscle and nerve damage becomes irreversible within hours, so causation turns on timing: when fasciotomy would have taken place with prompt recognition, and how much tissue would then have been saved. A consultant orthopaedic surgeon usually answers this, sometimes with a plastic surgeon where there has been tissue loss or reconstruction.
Other experts. Condition and prognosis often needs a plastic surgeon, a neurologist or neurophysiologist for nerve damage, a pain specialist, and care and employment experts.
Records. Neurovascular and observation charts, nursing notes, analgesia and drug charts, any compartment pressure measurements, operation notes for the original surgery and the fasciotomy, and later orthopaedic and plastic surgery records.
Want named experts?
Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.