Delayed breast cancer diagnosis after screening or triple assessment: which expert?
The breach expert depends on where the error lies: imaging, examination or pathology. A breast surgeon and an oncologist usually answer causation.
Breach of duty
- Breast radiologist or screening reader (matching the role)
- Breast surgeon
- Breast histopathologist
Causation
- Breast surgeon
- Oncologist
Breach. Triple assessment combines clinical examination, imaging and needle biopsy, and the breach expert must match the step that went wrong. A misread mammogram or ultrasound needs a breast radiologist. Screening mammograms are often read by advanced practitioner radiographers, and the expert should then share that background and know the screening programme's standards. A missed lump on examination, or a failure to biopsy or to act on a result, needs a consultant breast surgeon. A misreported biopsy needs a histopathologist who reports breast specimens.
Causation. This usually turns on the size and spread of the cancer at the date it should have been found, and on what difference that makes: breast-conserving surgery instead of mastectomy, avoiding chemotherapy or axillary surgery, and the effect on survival. A breast surgeon and an oncologist answer it, often relying on a radiologist's view of tumour size on the earlier images. Survival is often estimated with prognostic models such as PREDICT, and the experts will need to explain how they have used them.
Other experts. A psychiatrist if psychiatric injury is claimed, and a plastic surgeon where reconstruction is in issue.
Records. The GP referral, screening records, all mammogram and ultrasound images with their original reports, biopsy reports and slides, clinic letters, multidisciplinary team minutes and the later treatment records.
Want named experts?
Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.