General information only, not medical, legal or other professional advice. Read the disclaimer

Find an expert
General practice

Delayed cancer diagnosis: which expert?

A GP expert for breach. An oncologist or the specialist for the cancer concerned for causation, often helped by a radiologist.

Breach of duty

  • General practitioner

Causation

  • Oncologist
  • Specialist in the cancer concerned
  • Radiologist (tumour size at an earlier date)

Breach. The question is what a reasonably competent GP would have done with the symptoms, examination findings and test results in front of them at each consultation. The expert should be a GP in active practice, and their opinion should be measured against the referral guidance in force at the time, such as the NICE guideline on suspected cancer (NG12, 2015) or its predecessor (CG27, 2005). A hospital specialist is not the right expert for what a GP should have done.

Causation. This usually turns on two points: when the cancer would have been diagnosed after a timely referral, and whether diagnosis at that point would have changed the stage, the treatment needed or the outlook. An oncologist, or a surgeon who treats the cancer concerned, answers it. Where the case depends on how large the tumour was at an earlier date, a radiologist is often asked to review the imaging, and a histopathologist may be needed on tumour type and growth.

Other experts. Survival and life expectancy evidence usually comes from the oncologist. Psychiatric injury, if claimed, needs a psychiatrist.

Records. The full GP record (electronic consultation notes, letters and results), the referral and its date, hospital records from first assessment onwards, all imaging (the images, not only the reports), histology reports and slides, and multidisciplinary team meeting minutes.

Want named experts?

Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.

Send the outline

All clinical issues