General information only, not medical, legal or other professional advice. Read the disclaimer

Find an expert
Hospital

Delayed diagnosis of cauda equina syndrome: which expert?

The breach expert matches where the delay happened: GP, emergency department or spinal team. A spinal surgeon answers causation.

Breach of duty

  • Consultant in emergency medicine
  • General practitioner (if the delay was in primary care)
  • Spinal surgeon (if the delay followed referral)

Causation

  • Spinal surgeon (orthopaedic or neurosurgical)

Breach. Cauda equina syndrome is often missed at more than one point, so the breach expert depends on where the delay happened. A GP or out-of-hours clinician is judged on whether the warning symptoms were asked about and acted on. An emergency department is judged on assessment, examination and the speed of referral for an MRI scan. Where the spinal team was told and did not act, a spinal surgeon comments on that decision. Each expert should practise in the same role as the clinician criticised.

Causation. A spinal surgeon, orthopaedic or neurosurgical, usually answers this. The question is when decompression would have taken place with non-negligent care, and whether the outcome for bladder, bowel and sexual function would have been better. The evidence on timing is debated, and causation often turns on whether the syndrome was still incomplete, before urinary retention, at the point surgery should have happened.

Other experts. Condition and prognosis often needs a urologist, a colorectal surgeon, a specialist in sexual function and, in some cases, a psychiatrist and care experts.

Records. GP, out-of-hours and NHS 111 records, emergency department notes with triage times, the MRI request and scan times with the images, spinal team referral records, the operation note and later continence and urology records.

Want named experts?

Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.

Send the outline

All clinical issues