Delayed diagnosis of appendicitis: which expert?
The breach expert matches who missed it: GP, emergency department or surgical team. A general or paediatric surgeon answers causation.
Breach of duty
- Consultant in emergency medicine
- General surgeon (if under surgical review)
- General practitioner (if seen in primary care)
Causation
- General surgeon
- Paediatric surgeon (for a child)
Breach. Appendicitis is often missed at a first visit, so the breach expert depends on who saw the patient and when. A GP comments on a primary care consultation, a consultant in emergency medicine on an emergency department discharge, and a general surgeon on decisions made after referral to the surgical team, such as the timing of imaging or of surgery. For children the experts should have paediatric experience, for example a consultant in paediatric emergency medicine or a paediatric surgeon. The expert should consider the safety-netting advice given, since the diagnosis can be difficult early on.
Causation. A general surgeon, or a paediatric surgeon for a child, usually answers whether earlier surgery would have avoided perforation and its consequences: peritonitis, abscess, a longer stay, open rather than keyhole surgery and further procedures. Longer-term effects, such as adhesions or an effect on fertility, are often disputed and need careful evidence.
Other experts. A specialist in reproductive medicine where fertility is in issue, and a psychiatrist if psychiatric injury is claimed.
Records. GP and out-of-hours notes, emergency department notes with observations, blood results, imaging reports and images, surgical clerking and review notes, the operation note and histology.
Want named experts?
Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.