General information only, not medical, legal or other professional advice. Read the disclaimer

Find an expert
Emergency care

Missed fracture: which expert?

An emergency medicine expert, or one matching the clinician who assessed the patient, for breach. An orthopaedic or hand surgeon for causation.

Breach of duty

  • Consultant in emergency medicine
  • Emergency nurse practitioner (if one assessed the patient)
  • Radiologist (if the X-ray was misreported)

Causation

  • Orthopaedic surgeon
  • Hand surgeon (scaphoid and hand fractures)

Breach. The expert should match the clinician who assessed the injury. Many minor injuries are seen by emergency nurse practitioners, and where one made the decision an expert with that background is often more appropriate than a consultant in emergency medicine. Where the fracture was visible on an X-ray that was reported as normal, a radiologist comments on the report. The questions are whether the history and examination were adequate, whether an X-ray should have been taken, whether it was correctly interpreted, and whether the right follow-up was arranged, for example a fracture clinic referral or a repeat X-ray for a suspected scaphoid fracture.

Causation. An orthopaedic surgeon usually answers what difference earlier diagnosis would have made: whether immobilisation or surgery would have avoided non-union, malunion, avascular necrosis or the need for later operations. Scaphoid and other hand fractures usually need a hand surgeon. For a missed hip fracture in an older patient, a geriatrician may also be needed.

Other experts. A pain specialist for persisting pain, and employment or care experts where function has been lost.

Records. Emergency department notes and triage records, the X-ray images and all reports, including any later radiology review, fracture clinic and physiotherapy records, and the records of any later surgery.

Want named experts?

Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.

Send the outline

All clinical issues