Missed testicular torsion: which expert?
The breach expert matches where the delay arose. A urologist, or a paediatric surgeon for a child, answers whether the testis could have been saved.
Breach of duty
- Consultant in emergency medicine
- General practitioner or NHS 111 clinician (matching the role)
- Urologist or paediatric surgeon (if delay followed referral)
Causation
- Consultant urologist
- Paediatric surgeon (for a child)
Breach. Testicular torsion needs urgent surgical exploration, and claims usually concern delay. The breach expert must match where the delay arose: a GP, or an expert matching the NHS 111 or out-of-hours role, for advice given before hospital; a consultant in emergency medicine for assessment and referral in the emergency department; and a urologist or paediatric surgeon for delay after referral, including delay caused by waiting for an ultrasound scan. Adolescent boys are often seen by paediatric services, and the expert should then have that background.
Causation. A consultant urologist, or a paediatric surgeon for a child, usually answers this. The chance of saving the testis falls with each hour from the start of symptoms, so causation turns on the timeline: when the pain began, when exploration would have happened with non-negligent care, and what the operative findings show about the state of the testis.
Other experts. Effects on fertility are usually limited where the other testis is normal, but a specialist in reproductive medicine may be needed where there is doubt. A psychologist or psychiatrist may be needed for psychological effects, and a plastic or urological surgeon on a prosthesis.
Records. NHS 111 and out-of-hours call records, GP notes, emergency department triage and review times, surgical referral and review times, any ultrasound report, the operation note and histology.
Want named experts?
Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.