General information only, not medical, legal or other professional advice. Read the disclaimer

Find an expert
Hospital

Retained swab or instrument after surgery: which expert?

Breach is often admitted. A surgeon in the same specialty answers the effect of the retained item and its removal.

Breach of duty

  • Theatre nursing expert (count procedures)
  • Consultant surgeon in the same specialty

Causation

  • Consultant surgeon in the same specialty

Breach. Retained swabs and instruments have long been classed by NHS England as never events, and breach is often admitted after a serious incident investigation. Where it is not, the questions usually concern the counting and recording procedures in theatre, which a theatre nursing expert addresses, and the surgeon's responsibility for checking the operative site, which a consultant surgeon in the same specialty addresses.

Causation. The dispute is usually about the effect of the retained item. A consultant surgeon in the same specialty considers which symptoms it caused and for how long, whether infection or other complications followed, and what the further operation to remove it involved. Where the item was found during a planned procedure, the expert will separate the effects of the retained item from those of the original condition.

Other experts. A microbiologist where infection is significant, a psychiatrist if psychiatric injury is claimed, and a pain specialist for persisting pain.

Records. The swab and instrument count sheets, theatre records and the operation note for the original procedure, imaging showing the item, the notes of the removal operation, and the serious incident or patient safety investigation report.

Want named experts?

Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.

Send the outline

All clinical issues