General information only, not medical, legal or other professional advice. Read the disclaimer

Find an expert
Maternity

Shoulder dystocia and brachial plexus injury: which expert?

An obstetrician or midwife, matching who managed the delivery, for breach. An obstetrician on whether the injury was caused by traction.

Breach of duty

  • Consultant obstetrician
  • Midwife

Causation

  • Consultant obstetrician

Breach. There are usually two sets of questions. The first is antenatal: whether risk factors such as suspected large baby or diabetes were identified, and whether the mother should have been offered a caesarean section, which a consultant obstetrician addresses. The second is the delivery itself: whether the shoulder dystocia was recognised and managed with the recommended manoeuvres, and whether excessive traction was applied. The expert should match the person who delivered the baby, a midwife for a midwife-led delivery and an obstetrician where a doctor was involved. The standard is the guidance in force at the time, including the RCOG guideline on shoulder dystocia.

Causation. The central dispute is often whether the brachial plexus injury was caused by traction applied by the clinician or by the forces of labour. The evidence on this is contested, and the obstetrician must explain it with care, relying on the record of what was done and when. Where the claim is that a caesarean section should have been offered, causation also turns on whether the mother would have chosen it.

Other experts. Condition and prognosis usually needs a surgeon who treats brachial plexus injuries, often with a paediatric physiotherapist, an occupational therapist and care experts.

Records. Antenatal notes, growth scans and glucose test results, labour notes, the shoulder dystocia proforma with the times and manoeuvres used, the neonatal examination and the brachial plexus clinic records.

Want named experts?

Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.

Send the outline

All clinical issues