Suicide or self-harm after discharge from mental health services: which expert?
A psychiatrist from the same type of service, and a mental health nurse where nursing care is criticised, for breach. A psychiatrist for causation.
Breach of duty
- Consultant psychiatrist (same type of service)
- Mental health nursing expert
Causation
- Consultant psychiatrist
Breach. The psychiatrist should work in the same type of service as the clinicians criticised: inpatient care, a crisis resolution and home treatment team, or a community mental health team. The questions usually concern the assessment and formulation of risk, the decision to discharge, the discharge plan, and the follow-up arranged after discharge. Follow-up within 72 hours of discharge from inpatient care is a recognised standard. Where nursing decisions are criticised, such as observation levels on a ward or contact by a community team, a mental health nursing expert is needed.
Causation. This is often the hardest part of these claims. A consultant psychiatrist has to give a view on whether different care, such as continued admission, earlier follow-up or a different treatment plan, would probably have prevented the death or injury. Risk assessment cannot predict individual acts with certainty, and the expert needs to explain the evidence on this carefully.
Other experts. In claims by the family, a psychiatrist may also be needed on the effect of the death on family members.
Records. Inpatient notes, risk assessments and care plans, observation records, the discharge summary and plan, crisis and community team records, GP records, any serious incident or patient safety investigation report, and the inquest documents where there has been an inquest.
Want named experts?
Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.