General information only, not medical, legal or other professional advice. Read the disclaimer

Find an expert
Maternity

Third or fourth degree perineal tear: which expert?

A midwife or obstetrician, matching who examined and repaired the tear, for breach. An obstetrician or colorectal surgeon for causation.

Breach of duty

  • Midwife
  • Consultant obstetrician

Causation

  • Consultant obstetrician or urogynaecologist
  • Colorectal surgeon

Breach. Most claims turn on whether the tear was recognised and repaired properly rather than on whether it could have been prevented, which is harder to show. After delivery the perineum should be examined, including a rectal examination, to identify and classify any tear. A third or fourth degree tear should be repaired by a trained clinician in suitable conditions, usually in theatre. The expert should match the clinician whose care is criticised: a midwife for the examination after a midwife-led delivery, and an obstetrician for the repair or for medical decisions. The standard is the guidance in force at the time, including the RCOG guideline on third and fourth degree tears.

Causation. The question is whether prompt recognition and correct repair would have avoided or reduced the long-term symptoms, such as faecal incontinence, urgency or a fistula. A consultant obstetrician or urogynaecologist usually answers this, often with a colorectal surgeon on bowel function and on any later repair.

Other experts. Condition and prognosis often needs a colorectal surgeon, a specialist in sexual function and a psychiatrist. The effect on any future delivery may also need comment.

Records. Labour and delivery notes, the perineal assessment and repair record, postnatal notes, GP records, and any later endoanal ultrasound, anorectal physiology and colorectal clinic records.

Want named experts?

Send us the outline. A coordinator replies within one working day.

Send the outline

All clinical issues