The Limitation Act 1980 gives a clinical negligence claimant three years from the date the cause of action accrued or, if later, the date of knowledge under section 14: when they first knew the injury was significant and attributable to the treatment complained of, and who to sue. Knowledge they could reasonably have gained with expert advice counts. Section 33 lets the court allow a late claim, but do not rely on it.
Key points
- Time runs for three years from the date the cause of action accrued, or from the date of knowledge if that is later. Limitation Act 1980 s.11(4)
- The date of knowledge is when the claimant knew the injury was significant, that it was attributable to the act or omission alleged and who the defendant was; knowing it was negligent in law is irrelevant. Limitation Act 1980 s.14
- Knowledge includes what the claimant could reasonably have learned, including with medical advice it was reasonable to seek, judged objectively. Limitation Act 1980 s.14(3)
- For a claimant who was under 18 or lacked capacity when the cause of action accrued, the three years run from the 18th birthday or from regaining capacity. Limitation Act 1980 s.28
- The court can disapply the time limit where that is equitable, but the burden is on the claimant, so issue protectively or agree a standstill in time. Limitation Act 1980 s.33
The clinical negligence time limit in England and Wales is three years. Under the Limitation Act 1980 it runs from the date the cause of action accrued or, if later, the claimant's date of knowledge: the date they first knew, or could reasonably have found out, that a significant injury was attributable to the treatment now criticised.
The hard part is usually the date of knowledge, and much of the evidence on it is medical.
What is the time limit for a clinical negligence claim?
Section 11 covers claims for negligence or breach of duty where the damages include damages for personal injuries. The period is three years from the date on which the cause of action accrued or the date of knowledge (if later) of the person injured Limitation Act 1980 s.11(4).
The Pre-Action Protocol for the Resolution of Clinical Disputes "does not alter the statutory time limits for starting court proceedings" (para 1.6.1), so time keeps running while you follow it.
Three years from the later date
Three years from accrualTreatment and injury in March 2021: ends in March 2024
Three years from the date of knowledgeKnowledge on 15 November 2023: ends on 15 November 2026, the later date
After the last dayOnly if the court directs that the time limit should not apply
What counts as the date of knowledge?
It is the date on which the claimant first knew Limitation Act 1980 s.14:
- that the injury was significant;
- that it was attributable in whole or in part to the act or omission alleged to constitute negligence;
- who the defendant was; and
- if the act or omission was someone else's, their identity and the additional facts supporting a claim against the defendant.
An injury is significant if the claimant would reasonably have considered it serious enough to justify proceedings against a defendant who did not dispute liability and could satisfy a judgment (s.14(2)). Knowledge that the acts or omissions did or did not, as a matter of law, involve negligence is irrelevant (s.14(1)).
In Spargo v North Essex District Health Authority [1997] EWCA Civ 1232 Brooke LJ summarised the test. The claimant needs a broad knowledge of the essence of the causally relevant act or omission, and "attributable" means capable of being attributed, as a real possibility. The claimant has the knowledge once they know enough to make it reasonable to begin investigating whether they have a case.
In London Strategic Health Authority v Whiston [2010] EWCA Civ 195 a man with cerebral palsy had always known he was delivered by forceps. The allegation was that a junior doctor persisted with the wrong forceps for at least half an hour before seeking help. Knowing about the forceps did not capture the essence of that allegation, so it was not actual knowledge (paras 28 to 30).
When is a claimant treated as knowing what they did not know?
Knowledge includes what the claimant might reasonably have been expected to acquire from facts observable or ascertainable by them, or ascertainable with the help of medical or other appropriate expert advice which it is reasonable for them to seek Limitation Act 1980 s.14(3). A claimant is not fixed with knowledge of a fact ascertainable only with expert advice while they have taken all reasonable steps to obtain (and, where appropriate, to act on) that advice.
In Adams v Bracknell Forest Borough Council [2004] UKHL 29 the House of Lords held that the test is objective. Lord Hoffmann said the claimant's own character or intelligence is irrelevant, though they are assumed to have suffered the injury in question, and that a person aware of a significant injury can be assumed curious enough about its causes to seek appropriate expert advice (paras 45 to 47).
The Court of Appeal in Whiston treated that as a normal expectation that depends on all the circumstances, including a disability present since birth (paras 55 to 60). It still held that a reasonable person in his position would have asked his mother, a trained midwife, about his delivery by his early 20s, fixing him with knowledge in about 1998 (para 63).
Why does the date of knowledge so often turn on expert evidence?
The test is measured against "the act or omission which is alleged to constitute negligence", which usually comes from the breach of duty expert. In Whiston the court went to the particulars of claim to identify it (para 28). If the expert's criticism changes, the knowledge that matters may change too.
The records often show when the claimant learned of a possible link, for example in a clinic letter or a complaint response. In your letter of instruction, ask the expert to identify entries recording what the patient was told about the complication and its cause, and when. The date itself is for the court. Draft the letter on the footing that it may be disclosed (are an expert's instructions privileged?).
Do not assume time starts with the supportive report. In Spargo the claimant consulted solicitors in October 1986, firmly believing that a misdiagnosis had kept her in a psychiatric hospital too long. The supportive report arrived in July 1991 and the writ was issued in December 1993. The Court of Appeal held that she had the knowledge in 1986 and dismissed the action.
How do you count three years, and what if the last day is a weekend?
Marren v Dawson Bentley & Co Ltd [1961] 2 QB 135 left the day of the accident out of the count, and the Court of Appeal approved it in Pritam Kaur v S Russell & Sons Ltd [1973] QB 336. In Matthew v Sedman [2021] UKSC 19 the Supreme Court explained that the law rejects a fraction of a day (paras 37, 38 and 47). The part-day on which time starts is ignored, so the last day is the same date three years later.
If that day falls when the court office is closed, Pritam Kaur allows the claim to be brought on the next day it opens (Sedman, para 3). A claim is "brought" when the claim form is received in the court office, if that is earlier than issue PD 7A para 6.1.
For example, a date of knowledge of Wednesday 15 November 2023 gives a last day of Sunday 15 November 2026. The office is closed that day, so a claim brought on Monday 16 November 2026 should be in time. Do not plan on the extra day.
How do the rules change for children, lack of capacity and death?
| Situation | Three years run from | Provision |
|---|---|---|
| Under 18 when the cause of action accrued | The 18th birthday, or death if earlier | s.28, s.38(2) |
| Lacked capacity to conduct proceedings when it accrued | Regaining capacity, or death if earlier | s.28, s.38(2) |
| Died before the three years expired (estate claim) | Death or the personal representative's date of knowledge, whichever is later | s.11(5) |
| Dependency claim under the Fatal Accidents Act 1976 | Death or the dependant's date of knowledge, whichever is later | s.12(2) |
Capacity means capacity within the meaning of the Mental Capacity Act 2005 to conduct legal proceedings (s.38(2)); the old s.38(3) and (4) were repealed in 2007. Section 28 applies only if the disability existed when the cause of action accrued. Capacity lost later does not stop the clock, though the court can weigh it under s.33(3)(d). A later date of knowledge still gives three years from that date.
The 21st birthday is commonly taken as the last day for a childhood injury, as the defendant pleaded in Whiston (para 4). But a person reaches an age at the start of the birthday (Family Law Reform Act 1969 s.9(1)), and Sedman held that a whole day counts where the cause of action accrues at its very start (para 49). The cautious course is to issue by the day before the 21st birthday.
A dependency claim is barred if the deceased could no longer have sued at death (s.12(1)). Where the reason was the s.11 time limit, the court can disapply that bar under s.33 (s.33(2)).
Can the court allow a claim brought out of time?
The court may direct that s.11 or s.12 shall not apply if it would be equitable, weighing the prejudice to each side Limitation Act 1980 s.33. It must consider all the circumstances, in particular (s.33(3)):
- the length of, and reasons for, the claimant's delay;
- how far the delay makes the evidence less cogent;
- the defendant's conduct after the cause of action arose, including its response to reasonable requests for information;
- the duration of any disability arising after accrual;
- how promptly and reasonably the claimant acted once they knew the defendant's act or omission might give rise to a claim;
- the steps taken to obtain medical, legal or other expert advice, and what that advice was.
The burden is on the claimant (Adams, paras 54 and 55). In Whiston the Court of Appeal disapplied the time limit. The judge had accepted an obstetric expert's evidence that the surviving notes allowed a fair trial despite the lost CTG trace (paras 68 and 76), and any damages would be substantial (para 84). Longmore LJ called it a borderline case (para 91).
What should you do when a new enquiry arrives?
- Diarise the earliest date anyone could argue for: three years from the treatment complained of, ignoring any later date of knowledge. Work to it until you have firm evidence for a later one.
- Record the reasoning. The limitation date worksheet works through these steps and prints a one-page record for the file.
- Allow for the Protocol. Records should arrive within 40 days of the request (para 3.4.1), and proceedings should not be issued until four months after the letter of claim (para 3.20).
- Instruct the right discipline early, using Which specialty?, and ask us for an expert when a screening opinion is needed quickly.
- If time is short, issue protectively and ask the court to stay the claim while the parties follow the Protocol (para 1.6.1), or agree a written standstill with the defendant before the earliest date. Once proceedings are under way, expert evidence needs the court's permission (permission under CPR 35.4).
- Do not build the file around s.33.
Need a medical expert for a case?
Send the specialty and a short outline. A coordinator will reply within one working day.
Frequently asked questions
How long do you have to make a clinical negligence claim?
Three years under the Limitation Act 1980. Time runs from the date the cause of action accrued or, if later, the claimant's date of knowledge: when they first knew, or could reasonably have found out, that a significant injury was attributable to the treatment complained of and who was responsible. For a child, the three years run from the 18th birthday. For someone who lacked capacity when the cause of action accrued, they run from regaining it.
What is the date of knowledge in a clinical negligence claim?
Under section 14 of the Limitation Act 1980 it is the date the claimant first knew that the injury was significant, that it was attributable in whole or in part to the act or omission alleged to be negligent, and who the defendant was. Knowing that the treatment was negligent as a matter of law is irrelevant. Knowledge the claimant could reasonably have gained, including through medical advice it was reasonable to seek, also counts.
Does the limitation period start when an expert report supports the claim?
Not necessarily. Time can start earlier, once the claimant knows enough to make it reasonable to begin investigating whether the injury is attributable to the treatment. In Spargo v North Essex District Health Authority [1997] EWCA Civ 1232 the claimant had that knowledge when she consulted solicitors in 1986, although the supportive expert report came in 1991, and the Court of Appeal dismissed her action.
What is the time limit for a clinical negligence claim for a child?
A child is under a disability until 18, so section 28 of the Limitation Act 1980 gives three years from the 18th birthday. The 21st birthday is commonly taken as the last day, but a person reaches 18 at the start of their birthday, so the cautious course is to issue by the day before the 21st birthday. If the date of knowledge is later still, the three years run from that date.
Can a clinical negligence claim be brought after three years?
A later date of knowledge, or a disability when the cause of action accrued, may mean the three years have not yet run out. If they have, the court can disapply the time limit under section 33 of the Limitation Act 1980 where that would be equitable, considering factors such as the length of and reasons for the delay and its effect on the evidence. The burden is on the claimant, so do not rely on it.
What is the time limit after a death caused by clinical negligence?
If the patient dies before their own three years expire, the estate has three years from the death or the personal representative's date of knowledge, whichever is later (Limitation Act 1980 section 11(5)). A Fatal Accidents Act 1976 dependency claim has three years from the death or the dependant's date of knowledge, whichever is later (section 12(2)). If the deceased's own claim was already out of time under section 11, the dependency claim is barred unless the court disapplies that under section 33.
Sources
- Limitation Act 1980, section 11
- Limitation Act 1980, section 14
- Limitation Act 1980, section 33
- Pre-Action Protocol for the Resolution of Clinical Disputes
- Adams v Bracknell Forest Borough Council [2004] UKHL 29
- Spargo v North Essex District Health Authority [1997] EWCA Civ 1232
- London Strategic Health Authority v Whiston [2010] EWCA Civ 195
- Matthew v Sedman [2021] UKSC 19
Need a medical expert for a case?
Send the specialty and a short outline. A coordinator will reply within one working day.