General information only, not medical, legal or other professional advice. Read the disclaimer

Find an expert

Permission for expert evidence under CPR 35.4: field, name and cost estimate

The Royal Courts of Justice on the Strand, London.
Quick answerCPR 35.4

CPR 35.4 provides that no party may call an expert or put an expert's report in evidence without the court's permission. The application must give an estimate of the costs of the proposed evidence and identify the field, the issues it will address and, where practicable, the expert's name. Permission then covers only the expert named or the field identified, and the court may limit the fees recoverable from the other side.

Key points

  1. Expert evidence is restricted to what is reasonably required to resolve the proceedings. CPR 35.1
  2. No party may call an expert or put an expert's report in evidence without the court's permission. CPR 35.4(1)
  3. An application must give a cost estimate, the field and the issues, and the expert's name where practicable. CPR 35.4(2)
  4. Permission covers only the expert named or the field identified, so relying on a different expert needs a further order. CPR 35.4(3)
  5. The court may limit the expert's fees and expenses that can be recovered from another party. CPR 35.4(4)

Permission for expert evidence comes from CPR 35.4. No party may call an expert or put an expert's report in evidence without the court's permission. The application must give an estimate of the costs of the proposed evidence, identify the field and the issues it will address and, where practicable, name the expert. The permission granted then covers only the expert named or the field identified.

What does CPR 35.4 require?

Part 35 opens with a restriction: expert evidence "shall be restricted to that which is reasonably required to resolve the proceedings" (CPR 35.1). Rule 35.4 sets out how the court controls it.

Rule What it says
CPR 35.4(1) No party may call an expert or put in evidence an expert's report without the court's permission.
CPR 35.4(2) An application must give an estimate of the costs of the proposed expert evidence and identify the field, the issues the evidence will address and, where practicable, the name of the proposed expert.
CPR 35.4(3) Permission relates only to the expert named or the field identified. The order may specify the issues the evidence should address.
CPR 35.4(3A) On the small claims track or fast track, permission will normally be for one expert only on a particular issue.
CPR 35.4(4) The court may limit the amount of a party's expert's fees and expenses that may be recovered from any other party.

CPR 35.4(2) asks for the issues as well as the field. An application that says only "consultant obstetrician" leaves the court to work out what the evidence is for.

The rule is about evidence: calling an expert and putting a report before the court. On the multi-track, a party who obtains expert evidence before getting a direction about it does so at its own risk as to costs, unless the evidence was obtained in compliance with a pre-action protocol (PD 29 para 5.5(2)).

When is expert evidence reasonably required?

Form N181 (note E) says there is no presumption that expert evidence is necessary or that each party will be entitled to its own expert, and asks for a short explanation of your proposals. The King's Bench Guide 2026 says parties must be able to explain what issue the evidence is required for and what added value it will give the court (para 10.41).

A structured approach was set out in British Airways plc v Spencer [2015] EWHC 2477 (Ch), a pensions case in which Warren J held that a deputy master's refusal of all expert evidence was flawed. At para 68 he set out three questions, asked issue by issue:

  1. Is expert evidence necessary to resolve the issue? If it is, it must be admitted.
  2. If it is not necessary, would it assist the court in resolving the issue?
  3. If it would assist, is it reasonably required to resolve the proceedings as a whole?

For the third question, para 63 lists factors including the value of the claim, the effect of a judgment either way on the parties, who will pay for the evidence and any delay it would cause, particularly delay that might lose a trial date.

Admissibility is a separate threshold. In Kennedy v Cordia (Services) LLP [2016] UKSC 6, an appeal from Scotland, the Supreme Court identified four considerations that govern the admissibility of skilled evidence (para 44): whether it will assist the court in its task, whether the witness has the necessary knowledge and experience, whether the witness is impartial in presenting and assessing the evidence, and whether a reliable body of knowledge or experience underpins it. For opinion evidence, the first consideration is a test of necessity.

Where do you ask for permission?

Usually in the directions questionnaire. After a defence is filed, the court serves a notice of proposed allocation requiring each party to file a directions questionnaire and, for the fast, intermediate and multi-track, proposed directions (CPR 26.4(1)).

Section E of Form N181 asks, among other things, whether the case is suitable for a single joint expert in any field, and for a table giving each expert's name, field of expertise, justification and estimated cost. That table is your CPR 35.4(2) application, so complete every column.

On the multi-track, agreed directions will be approved only if they include provision about expert evidence (PD 29 para 4.7). At a case management conference the court will not give permission unless it can identify each expert by name or field in its order and say whether the evidence is to be given orally or by report (PD 29 para 5.5(1)).

The court may direct that evidence on a particular issue be given by a single joint expert where two or more parties wish to submit expert evidence on it (CPR 35.7). In the King's Bench Division, the Master will always consider this before giving permission for separate experts (King's Bench Guide para 10.44).

What you ask for is what the order covers

  • Application

    In the directions questionnaire (Form N181, section E): the field, the issues, the expert's name where practicable, and an estimate of the cost. CPR 35.4(2)

  • Order

    Permission for the expert named or the field identified, and for the issues if the order sets them. The court may cap the fees recoverable from another party. CPR 35.4(3) and (4)

  • Trial

    You may call that expert or put in that report. An expert outside the order needs a further order. CPR 35.4(1)

How should you describe the field in a clinical negligence claim?

Describe each field by the question it answers. The breach expert should match the discipline and role of the clinician whose care is criticised. Causation often needs a different specialty. In a claim for a hypoxic brain injury at birth, for example, our Which specialty? tool lists a midwife and a consultant obstetrician for breach, and a paediatric neuroradiologist and paediatric neurologist for causation.

The clinical negligence standard direction orders on GOV.UK, to which the King's Bench Guide 2026 refers (para 10.28), follow the same structure. The RCJ template gives each party permission "in respect of breach of duty and causation" for experts listed as "an expert in [field], namely [name]", each with a date for the report. Condition, prognosis and quantum are dealt with separately, and oral expert evidence at trial is limited to issues remaining in dispute between experts of like discipline.

In the questionnaire, state the issue each expert will address, for example "breach of duty at the GP consultations on [dates]", and list condition and prognosis experts separately from breach and causation experts.

Why does naming the expert matter if you later need to change?

The order follows the application. Under CPR 35.4(3), permission relates only to the expert named or the field identified. The structured order described in the King's Bench Guide names the experts where practicable (para 10.47), and on the multi-track a permission direction given at the listing stage names the experts concerned (PD 29 para 9.2). An order for "an expert in general practice, namely Dr A" is permission for Dr A.

If Dr A becomes unavailable or gives an opinion you cannot use, you need a further order. The King's Bench Guide says that permission must be sought to rely on an expert in substitution for one already permitted, that "expert shopping" is discouraged and a good reason is required, and that the court may make disclosure of the earlier expert's report a condition of permission for the new one (para 10.53). Our post on changing expert witness and expert shopping covers how those applications are decided.

Before you name an expert, confirm that they can meet the timetable and trial window, and check for conflicts of interest: the RCJ template requires experts to give details in their reports of any employment or activity raising a possible conflict. Our letter of instruction template is a starting point for a breach and causation instruction.

Need a medical expert for a case?

Send the specialty and a short outline. A coordinator will reply within one working day.

Send an enquiry

What is different on the small claims, fast and intermediate tracks?

Track Expert evidence
Small claims Most of Part 35 does not apply (CPR 27.2(1)(e)). No expert may give evidence, written or oral, at a hearing without permission (CPR 27.5).
Fast track The normal track only if oral expert evidence is likely to be limited to one expert per party in any field and two fields (CPR 26.9(6)). The court will not direct an expert to attend a hearing unless necessary in the interests of justice (CPR 35.5(2)).
Intermediate track Oral expert evidence is limited to one witness per party unless a second is reasonably required and proportionate (CPR 28.14(2)(a)). Unless the court orders otherwise, a report must not exceed 20 pages, excluding the CV and supporting material (CPR 28.14(3)(c)).
Multi-track No numerical limit in the rules. The number of experts depends on CPR 35.1 and the directions given.

For clinical negligence, allocation matters more than the track limits. A claim that includes clinical negligence must be allocated to the multi-track unless it would normally go to the intermediate track and the defendant admitted liability in full in its letter of response under the Pre-Action Protocol for the Resolution of Clinical Disputes, with no limitation defence raised (CPR 26.9(10)). Where liability is disputed, the claim goes to the multi-track.

Paragraphs (3B) to (3G) of rule 35.4 make special provision, including fixed cost medical reports, for soft tissue injury and whiplash claims from road traffic accidents.

Can the court limit what you recover for your expert's fees?

Yes. Under CPR 35.4(4) the court may limit the amount of a party's expert's fees and expenses that may be recovered from any other party. The King's Bench Guide says the Master may impose that limit before giving permission (para 10.43), and may order that the costs of expert evidence be reserved to the trial judge or limited to a set amount (para 10.51).

Get a written fee estimate from each proposed expert before you complete the questionnaire, covering the report, written questions, the experts' discussion and trial. A limit restricts only what you recover from the other side. Your agreement with the expert about what you pay is separate, so check that the expert's terms match what the court has allowed.

Frequently asked questions

Do you need the court's permission to rely on expert evidence?

Yes. Under CPR 35.4(1) no party may call an expert or put an expert's report in evidence without the court's permission, and CPR 35.1 restricts expert evidence to what is reasonably required to resolve the proceedings. On the small claims track most of Part 35 does not apply, but CPR 27.5 provides that no expert may give evidence, written or oral, at a hearing without the court's permission.

What must an application for permission for expert evidence include?

CPR 35.4(2) requires an estimate of the costs of the proposed expert evidence, the field in which it is required, the issues it will address and, where practicable, the name of the proposed expert. In most claims the application is made in section E of the directions questionnaire (Form N181), which asks for each expert's name, field of expertise, justification and estimated cost.

Can I change my expert after the court has given permission?

You need a further order. CPR 35.4(3) limits permission to the expert named or the field identified, and the King's Bench Guide 2026 (para 10.53) says permission must be sought to rely on an expert in substitution for one already permitted. A good reason is required, expert shopping is discouraged, and the court may make disclosure of the earlier expert's report a condition of permission for the new one.

What does reasonably required mean under CPR 35.1?

In British Airways plc v Spencer [2015] EWHC 2477 (Ch) at para 68, Warren J asked three questions for each issue: whether expert evidence is necessary to resolve it; if not, whether it would assist the court; and if it would assist, whether it is reasonably required to resolve the proceedings as a whole. Relevant factors include the value of the claim, who pays for the evidence and any delay to the trial.

How many experts are allowed on the fast track and intermediate track?

On the fast track, CPR 35.4(3A) says permission will normally be for one expert only on a particular issue, and the track is normal only where oral expert evidence is likely to be limited to one expert per party in any field and two fields (CPR 26.9(6)). On the intermediate track, oral expert evidence is limited to one witness per party unless a second is reasonably required and proportionate (CPR 28.14(2)(a)).

Can the court cap expert fees under CPR 35.4(4)?

Yes. CPR 35.4(4) allows the court to limit the amount of a party's expert's fees and expenses that may be recovered from any other party, and the King's Bench Guide 2026 says the Master may impose that limit before giving permission (para 10.43). The limit governs recovery from the other side. What you pay your own expert depends on your agreement with them.

Sources

Need a medical expert for a case?

Send the specialty and a short outline. A coordinator will reply within one working day.

Send an enquiry