General information only, not medical, legal or other professional advice. Read the disclaimer

Find an expert

Can a treating clinician act as an expert witness? Independence and conflicts of interest

A doctor with a stethoscope writing on a clipboard.
Quick answerCPR 35.3

Treating clinicians are not barred from acting as expert witnesses. Nothing in CPR Part 35 excludes them, and in Toth v Jarman [2006] EWCA Civ 1028 the Court of Appeal held that a conflict of interest does not automatically disqualify an expert: the key question is whether the opinion is independent. A clinician who treated the claimant is usually a witness of fact, and is rarely suitable as the independent expert on breach of duty.

Key points

  1. An expert's duty is to help the court, and it overrides any obligation to the party who instructs or pays them. CPR 35.3
  2. Expert evidence should be the independent product of the expert, uninfluenced by the pressures of litigation. PD 35 para 2.1
  3. A treating clinician describing what they found and did is a witness of fact. Relying on their opinion as expert evidence brings in the Part 35 duties and needs the court's permission. CPR 35.4(1)
  4. A conflict of interest does not automatically disqualify an expert, but a material one may lead the court to refuse permission or decline to act on the evidence (Toth v Jarman).
  5. Disclose any conflict that is not obviously immaterial when the report is served, or earlier if permission is sought for a named expert. The court decides whether it matters.

A treating doctor can be an expert witness. Nothing in CPR Part 35 bars a clinician who has treated the claimant from giving expert evidence, and in Toth v Jarman [2006] EWCA Civ 1028 the Court of Appeal held that a conflict of interest does not automatically disqualify an expert. The key question is whether the expert's opinion is independent.

In practice a treating clinician is usually a witness of fact on what they found and did, and rarely suitable as the independent expert on breach of duty in a claim about their own or a colleague's care.

What does the court require of a medical expert?

Under CPR 35.2(1) an expert is a person instructed to give or prepare expert evidence for the purpose of proceedings. Their duty is to help the court on matters within their expertise, and it overrides any obligation to the person who instructs or pays them (CPR 35.3).

Practice Direction 35 spells out what that involves:

  • Expert evidence should be the independent product of the expert, uninfluenced by the pressures of litigation (PD 35 para 2.1).
  • Experts should give objective, unbiased opinions and should not act as advocates (para 2.2).
  • They should consider all material facts, including those that detract from their opinions (para 2.3), and say when an issue is outside their expertise or they cannot reach a definite opinion (para 2.4).
  • A change of view on a material matter after the report should go to all parties without delay (para 2.5).

The Civil Justice Council's 2014 Guidance for the Instruction of Experts in Civil Claims adds a test: an independent expert would express the same opinion if given the same instructions by another party (para 11). It also says to establish, before instruction, that the expert has no potential conflict of interest (para 16).

Is a treating clinician a witness of fact or an expert?

Usually a witness of fact. The GMC's guidance on witness statements and expert evidence separates a witness of fact, who gives a statement about events they were involved in, from an expert witness, who gives an independent, objective opinion on specialist matters (para 10). A witness of fact should keep to what they know, based where possible on records made at the time (para 14). The GMC also recognises a treating professional giving opinion on the patient's current condition and needs, sometimes called a professional witness (para 10).

A party who wants to rely on a treating clinician's opinion as expert evidence is instructing them as an expert, with the Part 35 duties. No party may call an expert or put in an expert's report without the court's permission (CPR 35.4(1); see permission for expert evidence). The report must make clear which facts are within the expert's own knowledge (PD 35 para 3.2(4)).

Why is a treating clinician rarely the right expert on breach of duty?

The breach of duty expert gives an opinion on whether the care under criticism was of an acceptable standard. If the care was the clinician's own, they would be judging their own conduct. If it was a colleague's, they would be judging someone they work with, often within the defendant trust.

The GMC tells doctors not to allow any personal or professional relationship with individuals or organisations to affect the objectivity or independence of their evidence (para 12h). A clinician judging their own department will struggle to meet the CJC test of giving the same opinion whichever side instructed them.

There is no absolute bar. In Toth the Court of Appeal referred to Field v Leeds City Council, where it had held there was no assumption that an employee could not be an expert witness (para 110). But where an expert has a material or significant conflict of interest, the court is likely to decline to act on the evidence, or to refuse permission for it (para 102). The usual course is an independent expert with no link to the defendant, with the treating clinician giving factual evidence.

How close is the expert to the care?

  • No link with the claimant, the clinicians or the defendant

    The usual choice as the breach of duty expert.

  • Trained, worked or published with a clinician involved

    Disclose it with the report, even if nobody asks: the court decides whether it matters (Toth v Jarman). Undisclosed in EXP v Barker, it left the evidence with considerably less weight.

  • Gave the care under criticism, or works with whoever did

    Rarely suitable as the breach expert. Usually a witness of fact on what they found and did.

Nothing in Part 35 bars a treating clinician, but independence can go to admissibility as well as weight (Kennedy v Cordia, para 51).

What did Toth v Jarman say about disclosing conflicts?

In Toth v Jarman the defendant doctor's expert, a paediatrician, was a member of the Cases Committee of the Medical Defence Union, which was defending the claim, when he wrote his reports. The claimant raised the undisclosed membership on appeal.

The Court of Appeal refused permission to add this ground. Membership did not automatically disqualify him, because the committee excluded members acting as experts from its discussion of their cases, and he had left it before trial (para 109). But it should have been disclosed in, or at the time of, his report (para 112). The court's guidance:

  • A conflict that is not obviously immaterial should be disclosed by the expert to the instructing solicitors, and by them to the other side, even if nobody asks (para 108).
  • The court decides whether a conflict is material, and the parties cannot agree to keep a disclosable conflict from it (para 112).
  • Disclosure should come when the report is first served, or earlier if permission is sought for a named expert. A conflict arising later should be disclosed at the first practicable date (para 111).
  • The expert's CV should accompany the report and show any employment or activity raising a possible conflict (para 114).
  • A conflict can be of any kind, including a financial interest, a personal connection, or an obligation as a member or officer of another body (para 119).

Neither Part 35 nor PD 35 mentions conflicts of interest in terms, but every report must state that the expert understands their duty to the court and has complied with it (PD 35 para 3.2(9)).

What went wrong in EXP v Barker?

EXP v Barker [2017] EWCA Civ 63 was a clinical negligence claim against a consultant neuroradiologist over his review of a 1999 MRI brain scan, which the claimant said showed an aneurysm that ruptured in 2011.

The defendant's expert had trained him in neuroradiology for two and a half years, had written a paper with him that was missing from the expert's publication list, and had helped him become a consultant. The defendant had suggested him as the defence expert. None of this was declared, although the directions required experts to give details in their reports of any employment or activity raising a possible conflict of interest. It emerged in cross-examination at trial, too late to engage another expert (paras 27 to 29).

The trial judge came very close to ruling the evidence inadmissible, admitted it with considerably less weight, and found for the claimant. Dismissing the appeal, Irwin LJ held that the judge was fully entitled to take that view and that excluding the evidence entirely would also have been a proper decision. The adversarial system, he said, depends heavily on "the rigour with which experts make known any associations or loyalties which might give rise to a conflict" (para 51).

Does impartiality go to admissibility or only to weight?

It can go to both. In Kennedy v Cordia (Services) LLP [2016] UKSC 6, a Scottish appeal, the Supreme Court listed four considerations governing the admissibility of skilled evidence, one of which is whether the witness is impartial in presenting and assessing the evidence (para 44). In a passage citing Toth, it said the requirement of independence and impartiality is "one of admissibility rather than merely the weight of the evidence" (para 51).

In EXP v Barker the judge dealt with it through weight, and exclusion would also have been open to him. Either way, the instructing party may be left without the evidence it needs.

What should a conflict check cover?

Give the expert the names of the claimant, the clinicians involved, the defendant trust or practice and the dates of care, and ask them to confirm in writing:

Area What to ask
The claimant Have you treated, examined or advised the claimant, or been involved in their care?
The clinicians Have you worked with, trained, supervised or been trained by any named clinician, or published or served on committees with them?
The trust or practice Do you hold, or have you held, any post, honorary contract or practising privileges there?
Money and other roles Do you have any financial interest in the outcome, any role with a body involved in the claim (such as a defence organisation), or any personal relationship with a party?

Before the letter of instruction goes out, also ask for a current CV and a commitment to report any change. If the discipline is not settled yet, Which specialty? maps clinical issues to expert disciplines. When you ask exp-w to find an expert, a coordinator runs a conflict check before proposing anyone.

Clinicians have their own obligation. The GMC requires an expert to tell the instructing party without delay of any personal interest or potential conflict, and to continue only with written assurance that this is acceptable (para 25). See becoming an expert for the rest of the GMC guidance.

What if a conflict comes to light after instruction?

The GMC expects experts to consider conflicts at all stages of the proceedings, including professional or personal involvement with any party (para 24). Under Toth, a conflict arising after service should be disclosed at the first practicable date (para 111). For the instructing solicitor:

  1. Get full written details from the expert straight away.
  2. Unless the conflict is obviously immaterial, tell the other side and draw it to the court's attention. Do not agree with the other side to leave it out (Toth, para 112).
  3. Decide quickly whether to keep the expert. Replacing one can need the court's permission and may come with conditions, covered in our post on changing expert witness.

Need a medical expert for a case?

Send the specialty and a short outline. A coordinator will reply within one working day.

Send an enquiry

Frequently asked questions

Can a treating doctor be an expert witness?

Yes, there is no absolute bar. In Toth v Jarman [2006] EWCA Civ 1028 the Court of Appeal held that a conflict of interest does not automatically disqualify an expert, and that the key question is whether the opinion is independent. A treating doctor is rarely suitable as the expert on breach of duty in a claim about their own or a colleague's care, because the court is likely to decline to act on evidence from an expert with a material conflict.

What is the difference between a witness of fact and an expert witness?

A witness of fact gives evidence of what they know: for a clinician, their findings, the reasons for their decisions and what they saw and heard, based where possible on records made at the time. An expert witness is instructed to give an independent opinion on matters within their expertise, owes an overriding duty to the court under CPR 35.3, and can be relied on only with the court's permission under CPR 35.4(1).

Does a medical expert have to disclose a conflict of interest?

Yes. In Toth v Jarman the Court of Appeal said a conflict that is not obviously immaterial should be disclosed by the expert to the instructing solicitors and by them to the other side, whether or not anyone asks. It is for the court to decide whether the conflict is material. The GMC also requires a doctor acting as an expert to tell the instructing party about any potential conflict without delay.

What happens if an expert's undisclosed connection to the defendant comes out at trial?

In EXP v Barker [2017] EWCA Civ 63 the defendant's expert had trained the defendant and worked closely with him, and this emerged only in cross-examination. The trial judge came very close to excluding the evidence, gave it considerably less weight and found for the claimant. The Court of Appeal held he was entitled to do so and that excluding the evidence entirely would also have been a proper decision.

When should an expert disclose a conflict of interest?

Toth v Jarman puts the time for disclosure at first service of the expert's report, or earlier if the court's permission is sought for a named expert. If the conflict arises after the report has been served, it should be disclosed at the first practicable date. The GMC expects experts to consider conflicts at all stages of the proceedings and to tell the instructing party without delay.

Sources

Need a medical expert for a case?

Send the specialty and a short outline. A coordinator will reply within one working day.

Send an enquiry