General information only, not medical, legal or other professional advice. Read the disclaimer

Find an expert

Are an expert's instructions privileged? CPR 35.10(4) and the letter of instruction

Hands sorting tied case files in a box.
Quick answerCPR 35.10(4)

CPR 35.10(4) provides that the instructions behind an expert's report are not privileged against disclosure. The court will still not order disclosure of a specific document, or let the other side question the expert about them, unless there are reasonable grounds to consider the report's statement of instructions inaccurate or incomplete. Lucas v Barking, Havering and Redbridge Hospitals NHS Trust [2003] EWCA Civ 1102 holds that instructions include material sent as the basis for the report.

Key points

  1. An expert's report must state the substance of all material instructions, written or oral, on which it was based. CPR 35.10(3)
  2. Those instructions are not privileged, but the court will not order disclosure of a specific document or allow questioning about them without reasonable grounds to consider the statement of instructions inaccurate or incomplete. CPR 35.10(4)
  3. Instructions include the documents sent to the expert as the basis for the report, such as the client's witness statement and other experts' reports (Lucas v Barking, Havering and Redbridge Hospitals NHS Trust).
  4. An expert's drafts and earlier reports prepared for the legal team keep their litigation privilege (Jackson v Marley Davenport Ltd).
  5. Write the letter of instruction as if the judge will read it: neutral questions, a dated list of every document, oral instructions confirmed in writing and no commentary on the merits.

Expert instructions are not privileged. CPR 35.10(4) says so in terms, and in Lucas v Barking, Havering and Redbridge Hospitals NHS Trust [2003] EWCA Civ 1102 the Court of Appeal held that "instructions" covers the material you send the expert as the basis for the report, as well as the letter of instruction itself.

What CPR 35.10 gives you in return is a limited protection. The court will not order disclosure of a specific document, or allow the other side to question your expert about the instructions, unless it is satisfied there are reasonable grounds to consider the report's statement of instructions inaccurate or incomplete. The safe working assumption is that the judge and your opponent may one day read the letter and the papers.

What does CPR 35.10 require an expert's report to say about instructions?

CPR 35.10(3) requires the report to "state the substance of all material instructions, whether written or oral, on the basis of which the report was written". PD 35 para 3.2(3) puts it slightly more widely: the report must set out the substance of all facts and instructions which are material to the opinions expressed, or on which those opinions are based.

The duty covers oral instructions, so a telephone call that shaped the report has to appear in it. It is limited to the substance of material instructions: in Lucas, Waller LJ said there is no requirement to set out all the material supplied to an expert (para 36).

Are an expert's instructions privileged under CPR 35.10(4)?

CPR 35.10(4) provides that the instructions referred to in paragraph (3) "shall not be privileged against disclosure". The court will not, however, order disclosure of any specific document, or permit any questioning in court other than by the party who instructed the expert, unless it is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds to consider the statement of instructions inaccurate or incomplete.

PD 35 para 5 applies the same test to cross-examination on the instructions, and adds that the court will then allow it where that appears to be in the interests of justice.

Waller LJ explained in Lucas that, because CPR 35.10(3) compels the expert to set out material instructions, the party would otherwise be treated as having waived privilege in them. CPR 35.10(4) is designed primarily to protect that party, and to prevent lengthy arguments about waiver (paras 27 and 31).

What the other side can see

  • The served report

    Including the substance of all material instructions, written or oral, on which it was written. CPR 35.10(3)

  • Instructions to a single joint expert

    Copied to the other parties when they are given. CPR 35.8(2)

  • Your letter of instruction and the papers sent with it

    Not privileged, but disclosed only if the court finds reasonable grounds to consider the statement of instructions inaccurate or incomplete. CPR 35.10(4)

  • Drafts, and reports written for your legal team

    Privileged (Jackson v Marley Davenport). Part 35 gives no route to them.

Lucas treats everything sent as the basis for the report as instructions, so draft the letter and choose the papers as if the other side will read them.

What counts as "instructions" after Lucas?

In Lucas, a claim against an NHS trust, the claimant served two experts' reports referring to his witness statement, which had been sent to the experts. One also referred to an earlier report by the other expert. The defendant applied under CPR 31.14(2), which allows an application to inspect a document mentioned in an expert's report, subject to CPR 35.10(4). A Master ordered disclosure.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and rejected an earlier High Court view that instructions are only what the expert is told to do. Waller LJ held that "material supplied by the instructing party to the expert as the basis on which the expert is being asked to advise should in my view be considered as part of the instructions and thus subject to CPR 35.10(4)" (para 34). Laws LJ said the aim of CPR 35.10(3) and (4) is to make the factual basis of the report patent, which demands a wide reading of "instructions" (para 42). Disclosure was refused because there was no basis for suggesting the statements of instructions were inaccurate (paras 37 to 39).

In practice, the letter, the client's statement, any earlier expert report, the chronology and anything else in the bundle are all instructions.

When can the other side see the letter of instruction?

Unless you consent, only when the court is satisfied there are reasonable grounds to consider the statement of instructions inaccurate or incomplete. Laws LJ said the expert is ordinarily to be trusted to comply with CPR 35.10(3), so the other side cannot call for the instructions as a routine check: "There must be some concrete fact giving rise to 'reasonable grounds'" (para 43). Waller LJ's example was a witness statement served later that tells a very different story from the one in the experts' reports (para 38).

The protection therefore depends on the expert's statement of instructions, which can only be as good as your record.

A single joint expert is different. Under CPR 35.8(2), a party who gives instructions to a single joint expert must send a copy to the other relevant parties at the same time. The Civil Justice Council's Guidance for the Instruction of Experts in Civil Claims 2014 (paras 38 and 39) asks the parties to try to agree joint instructions and, where they cannot, to identify where they disagree.

Are draft expert reports privileged?

Generally, yes. In Jackson v Marley Davenport Ltd [2004] EWCA Civ 1225, the claimant's forensic pathologist wrote a report for a conference with lawyers and later a report that was served. The Court of Appeal refused the defendant's request for the first report.

Longmore LJ said a report made so that a party's lawyers can advise, or for discussion at a conference, is subject to litigation privilege, as are drafts circulated among a party's advisers before the final report is prepared for exchange (para 13). "The expert's report" in CPR 35.10 means the expert's intended evidence and does not reach earlier, privileged drafts (paras 14 and 15). CPR 35.13 gives no power to order their disclosure (para 12). Peter Gibson LJ added that privilege is waived only when the party decides to disclose the report it wishes to rely on (para 22).

There are two limits. Longmore LJ noted the served report was not on its face partial or incomplete, and said that if it were, the position might be different (para 18). And documents you send while the report is being drafted are, on the reasoning in Lucas, part of the instructions if supplied as a basis for the report. Replacing an expert raises separate questions, covered in our post on changing expert witness.

What does the CJC Guidance say about instructions?

PD 35 para 1 expects experts and those instructing them to have regard to the CJC Guidance. The paragraphs on instructions are these:

  • Para 20: give clear instructions and attach the relevant documents, including the issues to be addressed and the relevant witness statements and expert reports, "making clear which have been served and which are drafts and when the latter are likely to be served".
  • Para 21: seek to agree instructions where practicable, and that the experts receive the same factual material.
  • Para 31: if you send further documents before the report is finalised, say whether any witness statements or expert reports are updated versions and whether they have been filed and served.
  • Para 55: "The imperative is transparency." Instructions include all material that solicitors send to experts, which should be listed with dates in the report or an appendix. Omitting "off-the-record" oral instructions is not permitted.
  • Para 65: experts should not be asked to amend reports in a way that distorts their true opinion, but may be invited to amend for accuracy, clarity, internal consistency, completeness and relevance.

How should you draft the letter of instruction?

Write it on the assumption that the trial judge and the other side's lawyers may read it, with every document attached.

  • Ask neutral, open questions. Set out the issues the court will decide and ask for the expert's opinion on each. Avoid questions that assume the answer. PD 35 para 2.1 says expert evidence should be the independent product of the expert, uninfluenced by the pressures of litigation. PD 35 para 9.3 forbids leading questions in an agenda for the experts' discussion, and the same standard suits the letter.
  • Put disputed facts both ways. Set out each version and ask the expert to address each. The Guidance (para 58) expects separate opinions on each hypothesis.
  • List every document you send, with dates. Mark which are served and which are drafts (para 20), update the list each time you send more (para 31), and ask the expert to reproduce it (para 55).
  • Record oral instructions. After any call or meeting that changes the questions or the facts, confirm it to the expert in writing.
  • Keep commentary on the merits out. Leave out your view of prospects, counsel's advice, settlement and tactics, and remarks about the other side's experts. On the reasoning in Lucas, anything supplied as a basis for the report is part of the instructions.

If the discipline is not yet settled, the Which specialty? tool maps clinical issues to expert disciplines. Our letter of instruction template for clinical negligence claims covers breach of duty and causation. Run the conflict check before it goes out (see can a treating clinician act as an expert witness?), and name the expert in the application for permission under CPR 35.4.

What should you check when the expert's report arrives?

Compare the report's statement of instructions with your record of what you sent and said. A statement that leaves something out may give the other side the reasonable grounds CPR 35.10(4) requires. Ask the expert to correct any gap before the report is served. The PD 35 report compliance checklist covers the statement of instructions with the other PD 35 para 3.2 requirements.

Frequently asked questions

Is a letter of instruction to a medical expert privileged?

No. CPR 35.10(4) says the instructions on which an expert's report is based are not privileged against disclosure, and the letter of instruction is part of them. The court will still not order disclosure of the letter, or allow the other side to question the expert about it in court, unless there are reasonable grounds to consider the report's statement of instructions inaccurate or incomplete. Draft it on the assumption that it may be read.

Can the other side see the documents sent to an expert?

Possibly. In Lucas v Barking, Havering and Redbridge Hospitals NHS Trust [2003] EWCA Civ 1102 the Court of Appeal held that material supplied to the expert as the basis for the report, there the claimant's witness statement and another expert's report, forms part of the instructions. Those documents are not privileged, but the court will only order disclosure of a specific one if there are reasonable grounds to think the statement of instructions is inaccurate or incomplete.

Are draft expert reports disclosable?

Generally not. In Jackson v Marley Davenport Ltd [2004] EWCA Civ 1225 the Court of Appeal held that an expert's earlier report, prepared for a conference with the party's lawyers, was covered by litigation privilege and that Part 35 does not override it. CPR 35.10 concerns the report the expert intends to give as evidence. The court said the position might be different if the served report were on its face partial or incomplete.

Do oral instructions to an expert have to be stated in the report?

Yes. CPR 35.10(3) requires the report to state the substance of all material instructions, whether written or oral, on the basis of which it was written. The CJC Guidance for the Instruction of Experts in Civil Claims 2014 (para 55) says omitting off-the-record oral instructions from the statement is not permitted. Confirm any oral instructions to the expert in writing so that the record is complete.

What are reasonable grounds under CPR 35.10(4)?

The rule does not define them. In Lucas v Barking, Havering and Redbridge Hospitals NHS Trust, Laws LJ said the expert is ordinarily trusted to comply with CPR 35.10(3), so the other side cannot call for the instructions as a routine check, and there must be some concrete fact giving rise to reasonable grounds. Waller LJ's example was a witness statement served later that tells a very different story from the experts' reports.

Are instructions to a single joint expert confidential?

No. Under CPR 35.8(2), a party who gives instructions to a single joint expert must send a copy to the other relevant parties at the same time. The CJC Guidance for the Instruction of Experts in Civil Claims 2014 (paras 38 and 39) asks the parties to try to agree joint instructions and, where they cannot, to identify where they disagree.

Sources

Need a medical expert for a case?

Send the specialty and a short outline. A coordinator will reply within one working day.

Send an enquiry